Structures with Tree Forks

Designing structures with tree forks: Mechanical characterization
and generalized computational design approach

Ishani Desai
In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the degree of
Master of Engineering in Civil and
Environment Engineering at the
MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
May 2020

Timber structures have seen a resurgence in structural design in recent years due to a desire to reduce embodied carbon in the built environment. While many of these structures use standardized or regular elements, the recent revolution in digital fabrication has resulted in a variety of more complex and irregular timber forms, usually achieved through milling or other machine-driven production processes.

However, the organic nature of wood has also inspired architects and engineers to harness naturally occurring formal variation, for example, in the geometries of tree forks and branches, to produce designs that are more directly responsive to their constitutive materials. Compared to conventional fabrication processes for timber, in which the material is often processed several times to achieve characteristics that are present in the original material, this approach embodies little waste in material and effort.

 

Naturally occurring branching tree forks seem to exhibit outstanding strength and material efficiency as a natural moment connection, which underpins previous research investigating their use in design. This thesis by Ishani Desai advances the use of tree forks as a natural connection in structures through two specific contributions.

First, the paper establishes a flexible matching-based methodology for designing structures with a pre-existing library of tree fork nodes (based on actual available materials from salvaged trees, for example), balancing an initial target design, node matching quality, and structural performance. The methodology uses a combination of Iterative Closest Point and Hungarian Algorithms as a real-time computational approach for matching nodes in the library to nodes in the design.

 

The thesis presents results that systematically test this methodology by studying how matching quality varies depending on the number and species of tree forks available in the library and relates this back to the mechanical properties of tree branches found through physical testing.

Second, mechanical laboratory testing of tree fork nodes of various tree species (available locally in the area) is presented to quantify the structural capacity of these connections and observe the behavior under tree fork load transfers.

A structural score is developed to characterize the tolerance of tree fork nodes to imperfect matches in terms of structural capacity; these resulting geometries are compared to the previous matching-based scoring system.

The resulting approach is projected forward as a framework for a more general computational approach for designing with existing material systems and geometries that can also be expanded beyond tree forks.